Quality vs quantity: an experiment
There was a famous experiment that took place in an American university. It’s mentioned in many books about creativity, usually as a story about a pottery class.
The professor divided a group of students into two classes. He told one class that their grade for the entire semester would depend on making just one perfect pot, and that it was their job to ensure it was of the very best quality.
The other half were told they would be graded on quantity. The highest grades would go to the students who made the most work, during the term. For their grade, the work would be weighed, but not judged.
I have a vivid picture of that term.
Half of the students carefully considering what they might make, pressuring themselves to be perfect, rejecting every attempt they made and sending very little to be fired in the kiln. And the other half gleefully making and making, experimenting and playing, finishing pot after pot.
You can probably guess the result. The group who were told to focus on quantity also made the best work.
It’s obvious, really.
If you want to get good at something, you need to practice. A lot.
Preferably without your inner critic getting in the way, screaming that you’re not good enough. (While perhaps also adding, spitefully, that you will never be good enough.)
In reality, this experiment didn’t happen in a ceramics class at all.
It was a Beginning Photography course led by Jerry Uelsmann at the University of Florida, way before digital cameras made it easy to produce lots of images quickly and cheaply. But the result was the same.
Focus on quantity, and the quality improves too.
The story was popularised in Art And Fear, a book written by photographers David Bayles and Ted Orland. (If fear is an issue for you, I highly recommend it.) They decided that too many of the examples they used in the book involved photography, so they changed the setting to a ceramics class.
As a journalist, I’m not comfortable with this casual distortion of fact. But as a coach, I know this story illustrates a much wider truth. It is true for potters and for photographers. But also for writers, musicians, designers, performers and makers of all kinds.
Most of us struggle with perfectionism. We hold ourselves to impossibly high standards. And it often stops us making our best work. Or sometimes, any work at all.
Don’t get me wrong. I love that we are professionals.
We all care, deeply, about what we do. And we want to do it well. That’s important.
But there are times when we need to let go of our standards, to just play and get messy. To get out of our own way, and see what happens if we jump in and try something.
First drafts aren’t meant to be polished; they’re about getting the story down. All art is about experimenting, failing, and trying again to express your ideas. We can’t explore new directions and ideas, we can’t learn and grow if we need to be perfect, at all times. So let go of judgement, and get curious instead.
You don’t have to be brilliant all the time.
Some questions to ask, when you find your perfectionist taking over:
- What is this for?
- Who will see it?
- What’s the end goal? Will it matter if what I’m making is a little rough around the edges?
- How high a standard does it need to be, really?
- What would a really simple, rough, quick version of this look like?
- What would be fun?
No one but you expects every pixel on your Instagram feed to be perfect, every text or email to be witty and brilliant.
Your website will never be as slick as big brands or the leaders in your field, and your pitches and proposals don’t have to be honed to perfection to be effective.
But a flawed version of any of these things will do more for your art, your business, your career than the perfect one you’ve been polishing for ages but shared with no one.
Sometimes, done really is better than perfect.
Last year I had a client who was writing and rewriting his offer to prospective customers. He endlessly tinkered with the layout, the brand colours, the photographs and the testimonials. But he never felt it was fully right, and ready to send out.
In the end, I dared him to just send 20 emails to people he’d like to work with, saying: “I see you have a problem with xxx. Would you like me to fix that? Happy to give you a free 15-minute Zoom consultation to explain how.”
It turned out that was all he needed, to get the paid work he desperately needed.
I’m not immune from this.
Far from it! As I’ve written before, I’m a recovering perfectionist. But it’s a hard habit to kick.
Scrolling on Instagram a few years ago, I came across a collage by British designer/artist Rich Wells in which he declared: “Make more, care less.”
This hit me hard. Especially as I was procrastinating at the time, stuck in a loop of editing, tweaking and polishing the same few paragraphs for a page on my website that wasn’t really important enough to warrant such attention.
He isn’t saying don’t care at all.
He’s just telling us (and probably himself) to stop fretting and create without judging.
Afterwards, we can choose what to do with what we’ve made: what to dump or keep private, what to post and share as work in progress, and what to polish into something more permanent.
It’s a mantra I’ve repeated ever since, whenever I get caught in a perfection loop. You might want to try it.
What might you create if you aimed to make a lot more, and care just a little less?






What do you think?